State: Quitting Nurses Did Not Endanger Patients

Jan 17, 05:43 PM

Jan. 17--A state Department of Health inquiry has found that residents at a Smithtown nursing home "were not placed in jeopardy" by the mass resignation of 10 nurses in 2006, a spokesman said.

The health department's findings come less than two weeks before the nurses -- all Filipino immigrants -- are scheduled for a Jan. 28 trial in Suffolk County on charges of conspiracy and endangering patients in a pediatric ventilation unit at Avalon Gardens Rehabilitation and Health Care Center.

The Suffolk County district attorney's office questioned the thoroughness of the inquiry and defended the grand jury probe that led to the nurses' indictment in March.

Still, the health department is the second major state government agency to support the nurses' claims that patients were not endangered. The state Education Department, which licenses nurses, found in 2006 that the nurses did not abandon patients.

"This is the final straw," defense attorney Oscar Michelen said. "This is vindication that these nurses did nothing wrong, especially when it is the department in charge of patient care saying it."

Prosecutors and the nursing home's main owners, Benjamin Landa and Bent Philipson, contend that the nurses endangered patients by prompting a staffing crisis with their resignations on April 7, 2006. The nurses did so after complaining for months about working conditions.. However, records reviewed by the health department's Office of Long-term Care showed that the nursing home was fully staffed after the nurses' departure, said Jeffrey Hammond, a health department spokesman.

"The shifts were covered and patients were not placed in jeopardy," Hammond said.

The inquiry was begun in October to determine why Avalon Gardens did not inform state health authorities of the incident. Newsday articles on Sept. 23 and 24, 2007 reported that all shifts were covered on the day the nurses resigned and described connections between the nursing home owners' political relationships and the indictment of the nurses.

State law requires a nursing home to report any "mistreatment, neglect and abuse" to the health department.

The district attorney's probe began after a private meeting District Attorney Thomas Spota held with the nursing home's owners, attorney and administrator in May 2006. Spota had received $1,500 in campaign contributions from the attorney, Howard Fensterman, a prominent Democratic Party fundraiser. Fensterman and Spota have said the contribution played no role in the investigation.

Robert Clifford, a spokesman for Spota, said in a statement that the health department did not contact the the district attorney's office.

"The 10 nurses and their attorney are under indictment after a grand jury heard evidence that they endangered the welfare of children and a disabled person who are dependent on mechanical ventilators to breathe," Clifford said.

Assistant District Attorney Leonard Lato said the Health Department did not visit the nursing home or contact its administrator. Rather, Lato said, the department asked one of the nursing home's owners for records showing which nurses were on call to fill shifts left open by the resigning nurses.

"That's it. Nothing beyond pure numbers. No doctor was spoken with, no nurse, nobody who was actually caring for these children," said Lato, who said his information came from the nursing home's administrator, Susan O'Connor.

Hammond said he could not say whether an on-site visit was made by the state.

Gary Lewi, a spokesman for SentosaCare, headquartered in Woodmere, a group of nursing homes including Avalon Gardens, declined to make O'Connor available for interviews because she will testify at the upcoming trial.

-----

To see more of Newsday, or to subscribe to the newspaper, go to http://www.newsday.com

Copyright (c) 2008, Newsday, Melville, N.Y.

Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

For reprints, email tmsreprints@permissionsgroup.com, call 800-374-7985 or 847-635-6550, send a fax to 847-635-6968, or write to The Permissions Group Inc., 1247 Milwaukee Ave., Suite 303, Glenview, IL 60025, USA. State: Quitting Nurses Did Not Endanger Patients
Back to Current Headlines